Logo

Spacer Adoption Spacer Waiting Children Spacer Articles Spacer Voices of Adoption Spacer Adoption Community

Spacer
 
Send to friend
 
Print 
Spacer
Spacer
Photolistings
Spacer
Adoption Guide
Spacer
Find Agency
Spacer
Country Guidelines
Spacer
Special Needs FAQ
Spacer
Back Issues
Spacer
Adoption Events
Spacer
Help a Child
Spacer
Free Stuff
Spacer
Resources
Spacer
Spacer
Video Section
Spacer
 
Spacer
 
RainbowKids Newsletter
Join Now
 
Spacer
 
Contact Wizard
Contact Wizard
 
Spacer
 
Asian Children & Racial Identity: 10 Tips for Talking to Your Child
Helping Your Child See Past Race & Through Tragedy
April 01,2007 / Rebecca Hackworth & Martha Osborne
Untitled Document

In the midst of the heartbreak that all Americans, and many others through-out the world, are experiencing after the tragedy of Virginia Tech, there are a group of families who shoulder an additional concern. Some Caucasian parents of children adopted from Asia, and more specifically South Korea, are reporting an unexpected reaction to the tragedy from their children: Shame.

The same children who celebrate and identify, consciously or unconsciously, with Asian athletes, artists, teachers and business people in the media, are now inexplicably also feeling remorse and shame at finding out the perpetrator of the shootings in Virginia was an Asian man.

Cheryl Palmer wrote in with this comment, "I was in shock myself when we heard the news. My daughter is only ten years old and we adopted her when she was just an infant. She's always been extremely proud of her heritage all of her life."

She learned from another student at school that the shooter was, like me, mom, Korean.

"For the first time since Lacey became our daughter, I felt completely helpless. No matter what I say, I don't understand her feelings because I am not Asian. I can again and again tell my daughter this has nothing to do with her, but her pain is very real."

While Lacey Palmer may identify immediately and openly to the shooter because of their shared tie to Korea , the questions must be asked: "Will all children of Asian heritage react in this same way? How can Caucasian parents relate to something they have never experienced?"

Rebecca Hackworth, Director of Family Services for Dillon International, had this to say:

If children are feeling fearful or vulnerable in public, it is important to validate their feelings and not minimize their discomfort. Caucasian parents have the least capacity in our country to relate to racism or the circumstances that people of color experience in a time like this.   Many of Middle Eastern heritage were fearful for their safety after the events of 9-11.  And some of those folks were targeted in the aftermath of that tragedy. 

Your children could have similar feelings related to this event .  Perhaps you have access to people of color who could talk about these experiences with your children to let them know they are not alone.  These positive role models in a child's life can reassure your child that these are normal feelings.  We always need to equip our children about what to do when they are the victims of racism.  They need to turn to a trusted adult for help whenever they are feeling unsafe, anxious or fearful. 

As a parent of a transracially adopted child, each family must ask themselves how each individual child is processing this

Download

Racial Identification:

10 Tips to Use When Talking with Asian Children

 

terrible tragedy. The truth is, your child may be concerned or have a point of view that is completely different than what you are expecting to hear.

"The biggest mistake parents make in parenting is this," says Teri Bell, Special Needs Coordinator  for Americans for International Aid and Adoption , "Guessing . Every child will react differently to a given situation. As a parent, it's important to get the facts directly from the child. Don't base your beliefs on each action, each word your child utters. Listen."

How do you get your child talking? By listening . "Ask opened ended questions and don't be anxious to finish sentences or jump-into the conversation while the child pauses in speech," Teri recommends. With so much at stake, where does a parent begin? There are a few good conversation starters that give children room to make there own concerns known.

If the child has not yet heard about a disaster or tragedy that includes a great deal of attention on the race of those who were effected on either side of the situation, one way of introducing the topic may be by openly stating the facts. For example:

"Jennifer, there has been an incident in the news and I wanted to be the one to tell you about it," State the facts clearly, without emotion. Include race in the middle of the facts, and then conclude with an opened ended question such as: "I know this is a lot to think about. What are you feeling or thinking as you hear this?"

At this point, it is important to follow the child's lead , and not make any suggestions. No mention of how they might be feeling or what they may be thinking. A child may feel frightened, insecure, overwhelmed, or they may focus on a part of the issue that has absolutely nothing to do with race. The child's emotions may be jumbled and words may be slow to come. But the only way to know exactly what those emotions are, is to wait with patient understanding.

If the child simply clams up and does not want to talk about it, give them space to process the information and follow up within a few hours.

Another scenario and more likely in this particular situation by now, is that the child has already heard about the incident. A parent might say, "Obviously you know about this. What have you heard?" Try to be as calm and relaxed as possible. For a child whose answer is expressed in emotions, instead of words, one helpful tool might be to ask, What is making you cry? The answer very well may be more simple or complex than you had imagined, but you will only know the true answer if you are willing to wait and listen when the child is ready to share.

Frances Hoag, MSW with Catholic Charities brings up a controversial, but often silent fear of parents, The question parents should ask themselves is this: 'Am I planting a seed? If my child is not identifying with the racial aspect of this tragedy, am I telling her that she should?'" The opened ended question and practice of actively waiting to hear a child's response is the only way to know for sure.

Most transracial adoptees are proud of their heritage and of the role models that they have seen in the media.  So it follows that they also may tend to feel sadness or shame when people of their own nationality are in the news associated with some type of tragedy. Every parent understands that the there are good people and bad people and those in between in every culture and country.  Mental health statistics for depression, schizophrenia and other illnesses are the same world wide.  How cultures deal with those illnesses vary, but the rate of occurrence is the same.  Conveying this fact to our children, however, must be done with a sort of 'Emotional Intelligence'. What your mother may have told you with the words, "There is a right time and a right place for everything"

The bottom line is: Every child, in every family, is different and will deal with life's happenings in their own unique way. Only you can know your child, and only they can tell you what those feelings and thoughts are during this challenging time.

Rebecca Hackworth, MSW , LCSW, is Director of Family Services for Dillon International, Inc.  Founded in 1972, Dillon provides adoption and humanitarian aid in Vietnam , South Korea , China , India , Guatemala , Haiti , and Ukraine .  For more info, please contact: www.dillonadopt.com .

Martha Osborne is an adoption advocate, adoptive mom and adoptee. She is also the editor of the online adoption publication, RainbowKids.com , the leading online resource for adoption and waiting children. http://www.rainbowkids.com

 

Spacer
 
Send to friend
 
Print 
Add Your Comments
Name (optional)
Email (optional)
Your Comments  500 chars left
Rate this Article
Rate Here
Current Rating
Excellent (Rated by 107 readers.)
Readers Comments  (20 Comments)  View All Comments
Good point with the Caucasian term...so easy for each of us to miss this. I am Hispanic and an adoptive mom. I love your publication, and appreciate the opportunity to post a comment now and then.- GuatMom
Anonymous: Did you read the article? It's your comment I don't understand. I think the vast majority of readers, based on these comments, understood the statement and sentiment. Most mothers, thank God, also know that race IS an issue for our non-white children, even if we try to pretend otherwise.- MallorysMom
I didn't quite understand the comment "because I'm not Asian, I'll never understand how she feels." Are Asians strange beings from outer space? That's actually a bit comically racist ( I understand the earnest attempt not to be). - Anonymous
Instead of using the Caucasian term I wish you would have used non-Asian parent. I am a Hispanic woman who adopted a beautiful Vietnamese daughter and I can relate to the topic of this article. Have a blessed day! May we all pray for the victims and their families.- Anonymous
As an Asian American and adopive parent of a child from China, I'm glad to see this article to help non-Asian parents address the tragedy. - Meimei- Meimei
Thank you! I was so glad to see this article. We live in Northern VA and my 10 year old daughter (adopted from Korea) heard about the shootings while she was at school. She was horrified but when she found out the shooter was Korean she completely fell apart. She just sobbed and sobbed while I held her. It broke my heart to have no power to fix it. I'm so glad this article recognizes the feelings our children have and gives practical advice on how to deal with them. - Sissy
I'm a Korean adult adoptee and I have 3 children. Even as an adult, after hearing that the gunman was Korean, my immediate thought was, would people would look at me and think of the gunman? Rationally, I know most probably won't BUT it's hard not to let your mind wonder. In the end, I am VERY proud of being adopted and of my heritage, no matter how others may judge me. I tell my own children that they are each unique, that there is no one in the world like them.- Ginny
When my children (all Asian and under 10 years of age) realized that Cho had killed so many people..they asked: "Will people be angry at us because we are Asian too?" I wasn't sure how to reply. I was afraid that if I said no and someone did say something ugly to them that they would not trust me. I didn't want to say yes either!- Gina
Thank you so much for this article and your suggestions. I immediately had thoughts going through my mind when I heard the news. My children are all three from Korea and I wondered how or if they would react to the news. It's nice to have advice on how to respond or approach this issue. Thanks!! (FYI-My oldest son, 12, responded with "Oh, I would have thought he was from North Korea." Interesting how their little minds work!)- Kim B.
This is the first time I have ever heard my own fears voiced. "Don't plant the seed." I think this advice can be used in several areas with our children. I don't want to avoid any issues, but I also don't wish to grow the 'weed' of fear in my children's mind either. The hardest part, I have found, is when my children truly do let the pain out and I realize how much they have been holding inside without me knowing. - Denisa R.
I tend to not take advice easily, but this article offers a very solid, practical and sensitive approach to this issue. I think I'll join the chorus on this one: Thank you. - Kathy
Thank you. When 9/11 happened, several of my friends with children they had adopted from Calcutta faced challenges from strangers who thought the children were from the Middle East. One never knows how others will act, so it is good to be prepared.- Karin
Excellent article, although I need to point out that if the shooter was white, white children/adults would not feel the shooting was a reflection on them. It is immeasurably sad to our children and how they will feel about themselves as adults that people of color who commit crimes are blamed for their race, while white people who commit crimes are seen as an aberration. Parents, PLEASE be aware, and value our children's self-esteem above our own comfort in discussing race.- RaeAnne
It's interesting that one of your 10 tips for parents brought up that by talking about a serious subject like race, other topics may appear. With our 12 year old, her focus has revolved around the mental illness of the perpetrator. It's a new topic in our family. Thank you to the authors of this article.- Candice
It's interesting that one of your 10 tips for parents brought up that by talking about a serious subject like race, other topics may appear. With our 12 year old, her focus has revolved around the mental illness of the perpetrator. It's a new topic in our family. Thank you to the authors of this article.- Candice
I agree 100% with the open-ended questions! Parents should be careful to *not* imply that their Asian kids should somehow identify with the shooter just because the shooter is Asian.- Anonymous
I am a Korean adoptee and adoptive mom of a wondreful nine year old son. I still don't feel comfortable outside my home and cannot explain to others why this is. Let's talk about these issues!- Korea Mom
THANK YOU! The email list I am on has many parents who are not willing to face this issue with their child, instead telling their child NOT to feel bad, not to think it has anything to do with him or her. But what if your child feels bad and you don't even acknowledge it? Thank from a reader in Oregon.- Penny
Very timely, thank you.- Anonymous
I had my own fears about my child going to school after this, but he has been fine. Good teachers. I am going to use your tips (excellent, btw!) to continue the conversation with him.- Caren J.
Home   |   Contact Us   |   About Us   |   Advertise on RK   |   Link to RK   |   Site Map   |   Sponsors Login
Copyright © 2006 RainbowKids.com. Created and maintained by QualityClix
This site is optimized for Netscape 4 and Internet Explorer 4 or higher.
About Us Contact Us Advertise With Us Choose a Country Find an Agency Find a Child Home