Logo

Spacer Adoption Spacer Waiting Children Spacer Articles Spacer Voices of Adoption Spacer Adoption Community

Spacer
 
Send to friend
 
Print 
Spacer
Spacer
Photolistings
Spacer
Adoption Guide
Spacer
Find Agency
Spacer
Country Guidelines
Spacer
Special Needs FAQ
Spacer
Back Issues
Spacer
Adoption Events
Spacer
Help a Child
Spacer
Free Stuff
Spacer
Resources
Spacer
Spacer
Video Section
Spacer
 
Spacer
 
RainbowKids Newsletter
Join Now
 
Spacer
 
Contact Wizard
Contact Wizard
 
Spacer
 
Celebrities Adopting
No such thing as 'bad press'? Consider how the actions of others affect the adoption community in general
November 01,2006 / Martha Osborne
Untitled Document

Who has not heard the proverbial saying There's no such thing as bad press? Although none of us is shocked to hear this phrase in reference to celebrities, who often on account of their own bad behaviors seem to get themselves into thorny situations, not many of us would have ever thought the clichéd phrase would ever be uttered with regards to adoption.

With the recent flurry of international celebrity adoptions, and the bad press pop-culture-star Madonna has brought to herself by the adoption of a young Malawian boy (who has a very much alive and vocal father) many find themselves questioning whether the uproar is beneficial for adoption in general or whether it is exploitative and harmful.

Since time immemorial and in every culture around the world, there have always been both informal and formal arrangements for joining children, without parents or of parents unable or unwilling to care for them, with parents who willingly choose to care, nurture, and love them as their very own.

The mental links of adoption with infertility, the financially well-off and humanitarian efforts, however, are a much more modern development. Adoption advocates, families who adopted children and those pursuing international adoption, as well as many other child welfare professionals, lament the perception of Madonna and some celebrities pursuing international adoptions as akin to shopping for a child or acquiring a trendy new must-have fashion accessory and not as a method of forming and building a family.

There are certainly celebrities, such as Meg Ryan, who in privacy pursued the lengthy adoption procedures and legalities to adopt her daughter from China with little fanfare and media attention. Speaking on the Oprah show after the adoption, Meg Ryan said, It really gives you a lot of faith in things because you see how there's just no mistake when children are sent to you, however they're sent to you - clearly showing the consideration and thoughtfulness necessary and required in adopting her daughter and building a family through adoption.

The process of adopting from China is rigorous and thorough, yet fair. It is highly regarded in part because every prospective adoptive parent and family is treated in the same stringent fashion. There are no bribes or hidden costs to expedite the arduous process of being matched with a child. There is no special treatment because you are a well-known celebrity with influence or have deep pockets with unlimited financial resources. It isn't glamorous or exotic; there are no short-cuts. Prospective adoptive parents and the public in general appreciate the fairness and knowing no one is going to get special treatment or consideration. The child to be adopted into a family is of foremost concern, not the adoptive parent or family.

Although Angelina Jolie has been referred in many a joke on late night television as a serial adopter of third world orphans, her daughter Zahara , from Ethiopia, and son, Maddox, from Cambodia are obviously very loved and cherished by Ms. Jolie and their father, Brad Pitt. Jolie had a long while back gone on the record as stating, I want to create a rainbow family. That's children of different religions and cultures from different countries. (Although this quote has been resurrected as being recent, Ms. Jolie had made this statement many years ago).

Many consider and deride Ms. Jolie as head of the bandwagon leading celebrity international and transracial adoptions. Some appear confused and judgmental as to why she would pursue adoption when she hasn't endured infertility. Other detractors express serious concern the public will forever contrast her biological child as her real child with her adopted children. Showing an appreciation for building a family through adoption, she answers I believe I'm meant to find my children in the world and not necessarily have them genetically. (Editor's note: Good for you!)

Despite the controversy surrounding celebrities adopting internationally as a trendy fad, many see a bright side and potential for benefits. As Stacy Jenel Smith writes, the popularity of adoption among celebrities has been credited with helping to broaden the general public's definition of what constitutes a desirable adoption. That includes looking beyond the comparatively limited prospects for finding notoriously high-in-demand, healthy white infants.

As many domestic adoption professionals and parents who have successfully adopted would find hard to dispute, the cold hard reality is, many of these celebrity adoptive parents would not make it through an initial assessment with any legitimate adoption agency. Citing the traumatic losses the child to be adopted has already experienced early in life and the need for a stable and consistent home life placing the child's needs first; the well publicized multiple relationships and breakups, mental health issues, and even age considerations would find many celebrity prospective adoptive parents as unqualified were their celebrity and financial status set aside.

There are legitimate and necessary reasons for the numerous steps prospective adoptive parents must adhere to in building a family through adoption. Celebrities as well as others, intent on building a family through international and transracial adoption, should responsibly pursue adoption through legal, ethical and moral means and not approach it as purchasing a trendy new trinket to satisfy the need to be in style and in vogue. Fortunately there are those celebrities that do respect and follow all proper procedures.and unfortunately; there are those who do not. Let us each strive to see the difference between the two.

Spacer
 
Send to friend
 
Print 
Add Your Comments
Name (optional)
Email (optional)
Your Comments  500 chars left
Rate this Article
Rate Here
Current Rating
Very Good (Rated by 98 readers.)
Readers Comments  (29 Comments)  View All Comments
i was researching the interractial adoption amoungst celebrities for an english assignment for school. there are many different oppinions about the adoption. people like angelina jolie has taken it to far with her rainbow family. but other celebrities like meg ryan managed the whole thing out of the madia eye. it all depends on what people think of you to start with. if you have a reputation then it will follow you when you adopt.- sarah-may
gd facts read it all gd bye bye- brooke
i think you have done really well on this site and i totally agree with every thing you say i once adopted a child for alittle while but then he had to go i miss him loads please if you dont mind me asking please write back because i would like to chat again thank you and goodbi - sophia brose currington
Allegedly, Madonna offered the father enough money to raise his son himself. But he said he had remarried and wanted his son to have the opportunities she could give him. Again, all I'm saying is that I think people are making judgments about this adoption without really knowing all the facts. While Madonna's adoption may be "damaging" people's perception of adoption, it may be due to the fact that people want to believe everything bad they hear, regardless of if it is true. - Karen
But I've heard mixed messages about whether the 18 month Malawain residency "requirement" can be waived. Also, I know people who have adopted from S. American countries, such as Peru, where there was (at least in the past) a residency requirement, and they did not acutally "reside" there for the entire time under the "law." Likewise with the 10 day waiting period in most of Russia, some get it waived, depending on the circumstances. - Anonymous
I believe what she is discussing here is that Madonna did not abide by the rules of the Malawain adoptions. When adopting from Malawai you have to reside there for 18 months before adopting a child, Madonna was visiting there for 9 days. Also, when the father placed him in the orphange it was not permanent. Farmers in this country place their children in these places so that they can be taken care of until they make enough money to take care of them themselves. - Anonymous
I DO think people who have an idea that they do not need to follow the adoption laws in order to adopt hurt the system. My big question, and I have not seen it answered, is this: Who did the homestudy? I know from my British friends that there is a 3 year waiting list to have a homestudy done over there.- Cherie
I think it is unfair to accuse Madonna of "damaging" the public's perception of adoption. Some (not all) of the media tried to make her adoption controversial by not properly reporting the facts surrounding the adoption. Perhaps she should have anticipated this and done a better job of damage control. But seriously, celebreties adopting are not starting a "trend," they're just following what us regular people have been doing for a while. - Karen
Susan- excuse me, but unless you think that all international adoption is baby buying, you are off base. My daughter has a biological father and mother in Korea - how is that relevant. The biological father of Madonna's child put him in an orphanage and claimed he did not have the resources to raise the child. It seems we hold Madonna to a different standard because of her wealth and status. - Anonymous
He has legally adopted both Maddox and Zahara via the courts in California.- Anonymous
I don't think we should all look to the media for our facts. Madonna did a UK homestudy and adopted under their laws. She went through the process. She didn't issue a press release about this-the media jumped all over her. Due to the huge press Angelia's adoption brought, now all major celebrities are going to undergo press attention. If Meg Ryan were adopting now, she would be all over the front pages. It's "trend" the media is going nuts over. - Heidi
I found the reference of Brad Pitt as being "the Father" of Angelina Jolies children somewhat upsetting. What makes him the father? Has he chosen to legally adopt her children, or is he just the guy she is running with for the time being? If he has not legally adopted these children and made a lifelong committment to them, he is NOT their father.- Anonymous
thank god, your putting some perspective in this. It is difficult for the general public who does not really understand the adoption process to see the damage that Madonna has done to the adoption community. As you stated for god sake the child has a father. How dare she go into a third world country and buy a child!- susan
I believe it is unfair in to single out a family and accuse them of thinking of their adopted child as a trinket. It is also not fair to assume that the family would not qualify for a domestic adoption when they have to have gone through all of the steps required by every other family to adopt a child. Here is an interview of Madonna: http://www.madonnadiscography.com/.news/00111/Madonna-strikes-back-on-Time.com.html#news - Anonymous
Good Point. In a "search," some of the articles state that both Guy and Madonna adopted the child. This confirms that most of us don't know all the facts of this adoption, the actual laws involved or ever met the "parents." Yet, so many are so quick to buy into the media's attempt to say this adoption is bad. I've yet to see a confirmedl fact to support that this is an illegal adoption or that the child will be better off in Africa. Us not liking a person we never met isn't a "fact." - Karen
I'm not sure about the background of what, if any, homestudies were done, but what I find most curious about the whole thing is why is it just Madonna's child and not also that of her husband, Guy Ritchie??- JoAnn
I think Madonna adopted under UK law, not U.S., She mainly lives in the UK with her husband (he's Scottish) and kids. (hence her fake British accent) In her interview, I got the impression that the homestudy was done in the UK. Re: publicity - Meg Ryan is a great actress, but she does not generate the publicity Madonna does. Madonna may have contributed to this for career reasons(it sells tickets), but the downside is, even if she wanted a quiet adoption, it could not have occurred. - Karen
Why do we assume that Madonna did not follow the law in her son's native country? I adopted from Russia 2x. In some jurisdictions, the local court can waive certain rules, i.e., waiting periods. The fact that the court may have waived the residency requirement for Madonna does not mean it was illegal. Special treatment? Perhaps. But the court may have considered it in the best interest of the child to do so, considering all the publicity Madonna generates. - Karen
I chose Angelina as the 'positive' example in this article. She's a single mom with a clear example of simply wanting to parent a child. She went through a legitimate process, through a good agency. If you have beef with Gays or Lesbians adopting, please understand this: The USA does NOT restrict the adoption of children by G/L people. It is the choice of the placing countries to restrict the age of parents, the health of parents, the marital status/weight/family size/ ETC of families. - Martha O
"many of these celebrity adoptive parents would not make it through an initial assessment with any legitimate adoption agency" is simply wrong. Angelina Jolie worked with Wide Horizons for Children to adopt from Ethiopia. Adoption agencies assess the ability of adoptive parents to care for children. I was not asked about my romantic history and neither should anyone. China is not "fair," restricting the number of single applicants in order to discourage gays and lesbians from adopting. - Anonymous
I just don't think that adoption and infertility have anything to do with one another. MILLIONS of children are in this world are without families. Biological children aside, it is our responsibility as loving human beings to see to it that they are cared for in the best way possible!- Tracie
I understand your point here. While it is great that Madonna adopted, not following procedures, or causing negative publicity can slow down adoptions for other people. Countries may decide to stop working with the US if they think they are going to get bad publicity. In addition, these regulations are in place to protect against child trafficking, and kickbacks. - R
I adopted 2 Guatemalan girls (two differ adoptions) & it took only 13 months. Only Madonna & her social worker know how long their’s took. We all have to deal with the paperwork, the homestudy & the waiting. Are we jealous that it took her less time? Maybe. But let’s not judge her my friends. Let's be grateful that one less child will die in Africa this year. Let's put our jealous faces away and be happy for this new family. We wouldn't want others to judge us if our process took less time. - Racquel Turner *Muthahood*
My husband and I are in the process of adopting 2 kids from Russia. I personally think this is a wonderful thing that celebrities are adopting children. I was very inspired by Angelina Jolie and I think it's a wonderful thing that Madonna is adopting. No matter what the tabloids and media say I still believe these people are adopting because they want to help these children and they want to parent these children, therefore this is a win win situation for the kids.- Yesenia
We adopted 2 older children from Russia 2 years ago. It was a long journey. Yes, it is somewhat disheartening to see Madonna adopt a child without the tons of paperwork and waiting we went through. However, the bottom line is that child got a home...and we should all rejoice for him. The average person who pursues adoption is not wealthy...and struggles with finances to adopt. Madonna showed everyone that she is not too 'good' to adopt an orphaned child and take on that parenting.- Debbie
My husband and I have recently decided to adopt. I was very happy for the child that Madonna adopted, however I had two hearts. I felt hurt because we do not have the finances to just "get our baby". It will take us longer to save than what it took her to complete her whole process.- Ashley
what about Mia Farrow? - joanne
Thank you for your comment, Jackie and for reading my blog at http://www.adoptblogger.com . As I stated in the article, I don't have a problem with celebrities adopting; Many do it the right way. I have a problem with those who bend the rules just for themselves, not realizing the affect it has on other adopters and on the attitudes of the sending countries towards adoption in general. Keep your comments coming.- MarthaO
Very well written, Martha. You're right, you don't hear very much about Meg Ryan adopting, and the media just won't leave Angelina alone...but I also like what I have seen others comment about on your blog, and that is that many children are waiting...can it be so wrong to receive this attention?- Jackie Humphrey
Home   |   Contact Us   |   About Us   |   Advertise on RK   |   Link to RK   |   Site Map   |   Sponsors Login
Copyright © 2006 RainbowKids.com. Created and maintained by QualityClix
This site is optimized for Netscape 4 and Internet Explorer 4 or higher.
About Us Contact Us Advertise With Us Choose a Country Find an Agency Find a Child Home